We noticed the same with ours. I'm fascinated reading your "journal", as we just went through the same thing, only with "surprise, they aren't tadpoles!", so obviously we didn't do the breeding thing here. Ours were raised in plastic critter carriers, in pond water, in our dining room, where the min temp has been 70 degrees Fahrenheit. They've thrived, and I can't understand why lol. All ours changed within the last 2 weeks, and the oldest started eating at a week. As larvae they are exclusively daphnia and whatever else was in the water, and then black worms. Now they're getting pieces of earthworms from our garden.
Today is release day for 6 of the most recently turned, we're raising the remaining 6.
I'm truly not trying to brag that we did so well... I'm flabbergasted! Not one died, and we don't know what we did right!
?