Salamanders of the United States and Canada

R

rob

Guest
What does everyone think about this book? I'm thinking about getting it but I've heard mix reviews from really useful to filled with errors.
 
You mean Petranka's book? Well, if you want to know about ecology, distribution etc. It is excellent. But if you looking for a information on keeping them it is of course not what you want. For me it is impossible to keep salamanders if I don't know all I can know about their behaviour, ecology, breeding behaviour etc. So if you want to keep American salamanders...
By the way Salamanders of Ohio by Pfingsten (an older book) has also much information on ecology of many species kept by hobbyists.
 
It's an incredibly useful book, not only for the natural history/ecology info it gives, but also for the references it provides. If you want to know about American sals but can't look up the actual scientific papers, then this book is the best there is, period.

The "errors" in it that I hear about most often is the taxonomy, but that is no mistake. Petranka just has differing views about species concepts than some of the other field guide authors (notably Collins). There are some other range map errors but he identifies those in the introduction.

One real error that I found was that the photo of the larval Eurycea multiplicata is definitely not E. multiplicata! But that's it...
 
SOunds like a pretty sound book.

I think I will buy it. WHere does someone go to look up scientific papers on American sals? I've tried going to my University library and such, but I was curious if there was a good site online.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
  • jcjchdjdj:
    What are good worms for axolotls
     +1
    Unlike
  • AxieCrazy:
    Hello. I’m looking for some input. My axolotl is about 7 months old. I came home and her gills are completely white. I was reading that they do shed around this age. Could this be why her gills are white? The ph is 6.5-7. Nitrates are 80 Nitrites 0.5
     +1
    Unlike
  • AxieCrazy:
    My axolotl’s gills have turned completely white. she is about 7 months old. I fed her a couple of pellets to see if she would eat. One hit her head and she flipped out. Started darting all around the tank. Temp, ammonia, nitrates are all in range. Anyone know why this is happening? I pu
     +1
    Unlike
  • Anlucero:
    I believe my axolotl is constipated. I got him 8 days ago and have not seen any poop in his tank. I have a 20 gallon tank. No other tank mates. 2 hides and a bare bottom. I didn't feed him the last two days. His belly looks swollen and dark in color. I believe it is the food you can see. I fed him blood worms and soft quick sinking axoloty pellets. I tested his water today. Ph was 7.6. The nitrite and nitrate were both zero. The ammonia was 0.25 ppm. I was advised to cycle my tank due to the lack of nitrate. I added Seachem stability 10 ml to my tank yesterday and 5 ml today. I have a tank chiller. The water temp is set at 64. He is still active, but his tail floats up when he is moving about the tank. I am on the fence about fridging him. I also don't know how long to go without feeding him. I don't want to harm him. Please help asap. Thank you.
     +1
    Unlike
    Anlucero: I believe my axolotl is constipated. I got him 8 days ago and have not seen any poop in his... +1
    Back
    Top