Question: Home-made water cooling device.

GuyM

New member
Joined
Nov 27, 2010
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
New Zealand
Country
New Zealand
A friend suggested using a computer heat sink and fan as a cooling device for my tank, this would involve keeping the bottom of the heat sync in the water to draw out the heat and a fan to disperse it, pretty much in the same way a computer processor is cooled.
I know very little about chemicals and metals, would the aluminium sink disperse harmful chemicals into the water?
Is it worth steering clear of this technique, just in case?
 
I'm not sure about the heatsink, but fans are great for cooling a tank. If the heatsink is a peltier cooler, I think I've read about people using those with limited success
 
I have played around with peltier cooling elements, they are not very effective for something as large as an aquarium. Think how much smaller a processor chip is to an aquarium.
 
Hi Guy, sorry to tell you that peltier modules are pretty useless in aquarium applications. they are only around 10% efficient so you can put in more power than a 1/4 horsepower chiller into say 4 of them and cooling around 10 L of water- you only get a 1 degree drop.
sorry.

As for the Aluminum- not sure, will do some looking around for you though.
I'm not optimistic however- heavy metals in general aren't good for amphibians, and I would hazard a guess that the heat-sink would eventually leach itself into the water.
talk soon.
Rhys.
 
Ok Guy! here is what I found out:

aluminium is fairly corrosion resistant so it should not leech itself in any kind of measurable amounts into the water- however; it will eventually and a first sign you would have to replace it.
But a lot of heat sinks are powder coated and from what i can tell from some quick research, it is inert, so no problems there. all systems go and whatnot. :)

BUT:

Thermal Performance and Temperature Rise Above Ambient
Especially for cooling with natural convection, the hotter a heatsink becomes, the more effectively it dissipates heat. The thermal resistance of a heatsink decreases with an increase in the heatsinks temperature rise above ambient.

As a guide to the thermal resistance of a heatsink at a temperature rise T °C above ambient:

R(T)=K(T) x R(80 °C) (1)

Where R(T) is the heatsink thermal resistance at T°C above ambient,
R(80°C) is the heatsink thermal resistance at 80°C above ambient,
K(T) is a temperature correction factor read from the graph below corresponding to the temperature rise of T°C

Please note that the thermal performance at different temperature rises, varies from heatsink to heatsink and that the correction factor K is useful as an approximate guide only.

"
So basically the heat sink will perform better the hotter it becomes- which is not that hot in your case- around 20 degrees C, yes?

Sorry the graph didnt translate across,

So if you end up giving this a go be very careful and please let us know if it works or not.
Cheers,
Rhys.
 
Rhys has nicely confirmed my initial reaction: that the temperature differential wouldn't be enough to make a heat sink work. The fan alone will work, though, as it relies on evaporative cooling.
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    There are no messages in the chat. Be the first one to say Hi!
    Back
    Top