Question: Goldfish and Axolotls?

This is a bad idea. Not mixing species is a golden rule of keeping axolotls. When you get an axolotl, its tank is an axolotl tank only. I suggest finding another tank for your goldfish, and keeping your axolotl in an exclusive tank.

You run the risks of poor water quality, parasites, and diseases. What would you do if your goldfish got ick after you put them in? And as others have said, these are both very dirty animals as far as droppings go.

Also, they do not have the same habitat requirements. Fantails need water temperatures of 72+ Fahrenheit. You'll kill an axolotl if you have it in water that warm for too long, just as you'd kill a fantail if you had it in water cold enough for an axie for too long. If the temperatures aren't right, your animals are going to be stressed out, and more susceptible to diseases and other problems.

I know you care about your animals, but that's why I'm telling you that the honest bottom line here is that doing this would be a disservice to them. Neither species would have the proper environment, and frankly it would be neglectful and irresponsible keeping. Axolotls do not mix with other species. Period. It is an inexcusable risk.

Remember that you've got the privilege of keeping an animal that is critically endangered. Your first priority should be its most comfortable and healthy care. That's part of the responsibility of having an axolotl.

Again, I'm not trying to be mean or anything. You love your axolotl and you want the best for it. But I'm telling you straight up how it is, that if you have an axolotl, you have only an axolotl (in that tank).
 
Actually goldfish are fine as long as its above freezing


But my biggest issue is poor Natsu is SOOO stressed she HATES her 19 gallon she swims into the side and up out of the water.

I do not know what to do ... I can not get anymore tanks. I will ask on my goldfish forum if the Goldie's will be OK until next summer in a 10 gallon as they are very small.
 
Oh! Oh! I have an idea. What if you divided the tank completely? A watertight divider. That way its the same tank, but not the same water. :D

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk
 
I have no problem with doing that especially until I have room for another tank but I still think everyone here would flip
 
Could you not just buy a cheap second hand tank off ebay or what every you have over there?

We have preloved and gumtree and facebook groups that sell tanks really cheap.
I got my two 3 foot tanks for £10 each! :D
 
But my biggest issue is poor Natsu is SOOO stressed she HATES her 19 gallon she swims into the side and up out of the water.

Can you elaborate on this? I can't tell if you're saying the stress is figurative and if the stress is a direct cause of the aquarium size.
 
She is literally stressed ... her 10 gallon is too small 19 was a Typo

As for buying another tank money is not the issue ... space is ... I am completely out of space even if I buy double stands ... once I set up that 40 I am maxxed
 
How about putting the axolotl in the bigger tank by itself and rehome the fish ? Maybe also resist the urge to rehome more animals until you have the space to house them appropriately .. If I can resist it ( just) so can you ;)
 
Haha i have 5 axies and a double tank stand, i think my female might be going to lay eggs soon (the males are leaving 'jelly fish' everywhere!) and im trying so hard to keep telling myself im not keeping any haha :angel:
 
Please do not make it sound like I am going out and getting animals just because I want to ... I took the goldfish for a friend ... because they are not a popular animal to keep around here.

I am sure Natsu will appreciate the 20 long and I may go ahead and do that. In fact I am putting off KY plans for my Angelfish and giving the goldfish the 40, Natsu the 20 long, the Berta sorority the 20 tall and my Betta boy the 10 gallon

I do not think anyone will have any complaints with this ... in the meantime everyone is suitably housed they will just very much appreciate the upgrades ( doesn't everyone appreciate more space?)
 
Does Anyone have issues with the following plan?

Move Natsu to the 20 long by herself, Move the goldfish to the 40 long, I don't think you guys care about my two Betta Tank plans lol.

I only use Sand in my Axolotl and Goldfish tanks ... And fake plants... I would love to use real but my axolotl is a bulldozer lol ... Love my little lady so much.

Only the best for my little ones ... yeah I can be stubborn but in the end I will only do whats best for my pets :) If I had the space Natsu would get her 20 long right now ... 6 months seems SOOO far away.
 
They sound like good plans. I'd love to see your sorority, I have one of my own in a 29. A 10 is a TON of space for a boy betta, he'll love that.

I'm sure Natsu will appreciate the 20 long, it never hurts to go bigger for the animal itself. Do post pictures when you get her all settled in her new home eventually :)
 
I have it posted on my betta forum.

Natsu has had a 20 long to herself before and it was wonderful :) She was so happy, I did get her a friend and she did not mind but I will just leave her by herself :) More space :)
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    There are no messages in the chat. Be the first one to say Hi!
    Back
    Top