Distinguishing different cresteds

A

aaron

Guest
I've recently aquired 12 crested newts. They are not in breeding dress and they aren't karelinii. I know that they can be cristatus, carnifex, or dobrogicus. They are from Ukraine. What i'm looking for is a way to distinguish the different types outside of the breeding season. Thanks,

~Aaron
 
Hi Aaron,

Well, I guess they are most likely T. cristatus.

T. dobrogicus is pretty unlikely and you can't mistake them for anything else because they are _really_ slender...

Without first-hand experience with all taxa, a scientific indentification isn't possible, especially with few live specimens. However, have a look at the nice pics from the following paper which may help you to try some educated guesses...
Arntzen, J. W. & G. P. Wallis. 1999. Geographic variation and taxonomy of crested newts (Triturus cristatus superspecies): morphological and mitochondrial DNA data. Contributions to Zoology, 68 (3): 181-203.
(This paper was available online but the old URL doesn't work - I'll check it out and post it ASAP.)

Best wishes,
kai
 
Hi.

If they're really from the Ukraine, then they are
either karelinii (which you've dismissed), cristatus or dobrogicus. dobrogicus has a very limited range in the Ukraine (see my map at
http://www.darkwave.org.uk/~caleb/tricri.html),
so it's most likely to be cristatus.

cristatus and karelinii are often exported from the Ukraine, but I've never heard of dobrogicus being exported.

karelinii usually have yellow/orange and black throats, carnifex and cristatus have black with white speckling. carnifex females almost always have a yellow stripe along the back, males sometimes do. In terms of bulkiness, karelinii>cristatus>carnifex>dobrogicus.

Hope that helps
 
I must apologise Caleb - your link submission slipped through the cracks. I have now added it.
 
I'm sure they aren't karelinii because I already have a pair of them, and they are nothing alike. These new cresteds are a very dark greyish brown with black spots(spots are similar to karelinii) and they have the white flecks of color on the lower regions. They have school-bus yellow colored bellies with black spots.

~Aaron
 
Kai, I was just wondering if you ever found that link. Thanks,

~Aaron
 
Sorry, forgwet about it. I'll try next week - please remind me if necessary.

happy.gif

kai
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
  • hhlarmore:
    Had a question that I just want to be sure of. My marbled newt is a little over a year old and has started to develop and I noticed that he is starting to swell a little below his abdomen. I guess I’d like to know if they are his testes or if I need to be concerned.
     +2
    Unlike
  • FragileCorpse:
    Guess no one answers anything here, gonna have to make a post I gues
     +2
    Unlike
  • SkudulfXD:
    Hello!!! I'm new to this website and idk how to ask a proper question on the designated spot yet, so I'll ask here, I'm a first time Axolotl owner, and my dad used to run an aquarium store, anyways... Orca, my Axolotl, seems to loose parts of her toes on one limb from time to time, I can't seem to find the problem. Tempature is well, she doesn't seem to have any infections or anything, though. And I'm not sure if I'll be able to find a vet in Brazil for amphibians that are in a reasonable distance to drive without stressing Orca out too much
    20241201_124749.jpg
    20241201_124838.jpg
    +1
    Unlike
  • Toast69:
    Hello, I’m hoping for some advice please. Our Axolotl is about 7 months old. Till now no problem. Eating, growing and happy. He’s simply stopped eating. Everything looks fine, his gills look healthy and no apparent signs of sickness. He just swims past the pellets and bloodworm like he can’t smell it. I don’t think it’s a blockage either. Any ideas and suggestions for treatment would be much appreciated. Thank you!
     +1
    Unlike
  • Olivia:):
    what is the best thermometer for my axolotl tank? preferably on Amazon, and can you show me a picture or a link:) thank you!
     +1
    Unlike
  • Olivia:):
    Also should I have a fan hitting my axolotl tank 24/7?
     +1
    Unlike
  • thenewtster:
    does anyone know how to care for mud salamanders:)thanks.
     +1
    Unlike
  • thenewtster:
    hello
     +1
    Unlike
  • thenewtster:
    how long do mud salamanders live
     +1
    Unlike
  • thenewtster:
    im new to the salamaner comunity
     +1
    Unlike
  • thenewtster:
    hey guys, again im resarching mud salamander babys and there care:)
     +1
    Unlike
    thenewtster: hey guys, again im resarching mud salamander babys and there care:) +1
    Back
    Top