Concept DIY Filter. Input please :P

[totallyrad]

So I was going to build a canister filter and then this idea popped into my head. I would just buy a cheap canister filter but I already have an extra water pump and so it would cost my like 10 dollars to make this.

Anyway,

Step 1: Submersible pump at bottom encased in sea sponge acts as sponge filter.

Step 2: Passes through first bottle chamber and filter media of choice.

Step 3: Passes through second bottle chamber and filter media of choice.

Step 4: Second bottle has holes drilled to act as a spray bar

Step 5: Water re-entry into tank.


So drew up the design. Sounds like it could work. Just need to make water tight seals with silicone where tubing meets bottle. Also was thinking of using the "smart water" bottles with the squirt mouth piece and fitting tubing over the mouth pieces and sealing.

Not a very original idea but I put some minor twists on a common concept.

Bottles will be mounted on top of back wall of aquarium. Need ideas for mounting!
Oh and this project is for a 10 gallon.

Let me know what you think. If it would work, pros, cons, etc.
Picture below.
Also posted on planted tank

 

[John]

It should work, but by bringing it out of the water you are risking leaks. In my experience, first time DIY projects like this invariably leak in the end, especially when you're not at home to notice it...

Keep in mind, even some commercial filters might leak. In the end, I would advise hunting around the internet for a cheap or used canister filter!

 

[totallyrad]

Hey there, Yes I've done my fair share of DIY projects but most the time I end up scrapping them because of functionality or it looks crappy lol. I only wanted to try this because I have most the supplies already. But I think I'm going to get a zoo med 501 off amazon for 35 bucks (this filter is for a 10 gallon I have.)

I had a fluval 205 but sold it because it was too powerful for my 20 gallon axie tank. Sold everything and got out of the hobby but now I miss axies too much so I gotta get another one. This filter is for my cherry shrimp tank. Anyway, enough shinfo ha. Thanks for the input.